继续重选50多年来的奥斯卡最佳外语片

2010-03-06T13:45:12Z

我认为，在大多数年份，奥斯卡最佳外语片的提名和获奖影片的水准都高于最佳影片，这种现象很正常，毕竟是全世界的优秀电影和美国一国的比较。但这个奖项的遴选考虑十分复杂，肯定不能认为某国推送的候选影片就是该国当年的最佳影片，所以这里面提名或获奖的影片远远无法代表当年度最优秀的非英语片，历史上许多好的电影都和奖项无缘，而下面这份名单里的不少提名，现在来看都是平庸之作。

1947-1955年的奥斯卡最佳外语片是个荣誉奖，未展开竞争，这里略过不提，从1956年开始重选。规则和上一篇一样，黄色是官方结果，红色是我的选择，当年未标红说明我的选择和官方一致。算下来这次有40%的吻合率，比上一篇高多了。

Year	Film title used in nomination	Director
1956 (29th)	*La Strada*	Federico Fellini
	The Captain of Köpenick	Helmut Käutner
	Gervaise	René Clément
	Harp of Burma	Kon Ichikawa
	Qivitoq	Erik Balling
1957 (30th)	*The Nights of Cabiria*	Federico Fellini
	The Devil Came at Night	Robert Siodmak
	Gates of Paris	René Clair
	Mother India	Mehboob Khan
	Nine Lives	Arne Skouen
1958 (31st)	*My Uncle*	Jacques Tati
	Arms and the Man	Franz Peter Wirth
	La Venganza	Juan Antonio Bardem
	The Road a Year Long	Giuseppe De Santis
	The Usual Unidentified Thieves	Mario Monicelli
1959 (32nd)	*Black Orpheus*	Marcel Camus
	The Bridge	Bernhard Wicki
	The Great War	Mario Monicelli
	Paw	Astrid Henning-Jensen
	The Village on the River	Fons Rademakers
1960 (33rd)	*The Virgin Spring*	Ingmar Bergman
	Kapò	Gillo Pontecorvo
	La Vérité	Henri-Georges Clouzot
	Macario	Roberto Gavaldón
	The Ninth Circle	France Štiglic
1961 (34th)	*Through a Glass Darkly*	Ingmar Bergman
	Harry and the Butler	Bent Christensen
	Immortal Love	Keisuke Kinoshita
	The Important Man	Ismael Rodríguez
	Plácido	Luis García Berlanga
1962 (35th)	*Sundays and Cybele*	Serge Bourguignon
	Electra	Michael Cacoyannis
	The Four Days of Naples	Nanni Loy
	Keeper of Promises (The Given Word)	Anselmo Duarte
	Tlayucan	Luis Alcoriza
1963 (36th)	*Federico Fellini’s 8½*	Federico Fellini
	Knife in the Water	Roman Polanski
	Los Tarantos	Francisco Rovira Beleta
	The Red Lanterns	Vasilis Georgiadis
	Twin Sisters of Kyoto	Noboru Nakamura
1964 (37th)	*Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow*	Vittorio De Sica
	Raven’s End	Bo Widerberg
	Sallah	Ephraim Kishon
	The Umbrellas of Cherbourg	Jacques Demy
	Woman in the Dunes	Hiroshi Teshigahara
1965 (38th)	*The Shop on Main Street*	Ján Kadár Elmar Klos
	Blood on the Land	Vasilis Georgiadis
	Dear John	Lars-Magnus Lindgren
	Kwaidan	Masaki Kobayashi
	Marriage Italian Style	Vittorio De Sica
1966 (39th)	*A Man and a Woman*	Claude Lelouch
	The Battle of Algiers	Gillo Pontecorvo
	Loves of a Blonde	Miloš Forman
	Pharaoh	Jerzy Kawalerowicz
	Three	Aleksandar Petrović
1967 (40th)	*Closely Watched Trains*	Jiří Menzel
	El Amor Brujo	Francisco Rovira Beleta
	I Even Met Happy Gypsies	Aleksandar Petrović
	Live for Life	Claude Lelouch
	Portrait of Chieko	Noboru Nakamura
1968 (41st)	*War and Peace*	Sergei Bondarchuk
	The Boys of Paul Street	Zoltán Fábri
	The Firemen’s Ball	Miloš Forman
	The Girl with the Pistol	Mario Monicelli
	Stolen Kisses	François Truffaut
1969 (42nd)	Z	Costa-Gavras
	Ådalen ‘31	Bo Widerberg
	The Battle of Neretva	Veljko Bulajić
	The Brothers Karamazov	Kirill Lavrov Ivan Pyryev Mikhail Ulyanov
	My Night with Maud	Eric Rohmer
1970 (43rd)	*Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion*	Elio Petri
	First Love	Maximilian Schell
	Hoa-Binh	Raoul Coutard
	Paix Sur Les Champs	Jacques Boigelot
	Tristana	Luis Buñuel
1971 (44th)	*The Garden of the Finzi Continis*	Vittorio De Sica
	Dodes’ka-Den	Akira Kurosawa
	The Emigrants	Jan Troell
	The Policeman	Ephraim Kishon
	Tchaikovsky	Igor Talankin
1972 (45th)	*The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie*	Luis Buñuel
	The Dawns Here Are Quiet	Stanislav Rostotsky
	I Love You Rosa	Moshé Mizrahi
	My Dearest Señorita	Jaime de Armiñán
	The New Land	Jan Troell
1973 (46th)	*Day for Night*	François Truffaut
	The House on Chelouche Street	Moshé Mizrahi
	L’Invitation	Claude Goretta
	The Pedestrian	Maximilian Schell
	Turkish Delight	Paul Verhoeven
1974 (47th)	*Amarcord*	Federico Fellini
	Cats’ Play	Károly Makk
	The Deluge	Jerzy Hoffman
	Lacombe, Lucien	Louis Malle
	The Truce	Sergio Renán
1975 (48th)	*Dersu Uzala*	Akira Kurosawa
	Land of Promise	Andrzej Wajda
	Letters from Marusia	Miguel Littín
	Sandakan No. 8	Kei Kumai
	Scent of a Woman	Dino Risi
1976 (49th)	*Black and White in Color*	Jean-Jacques Annaud
	Cousin, Cousine	Jean-Charles Tacchella
	Jacob, the Liar	Frank Beyer
	Nights and Days	Jerzy Antczak
	Seven Beauties	Lina Wertmüller
1977 (50th)	*Madame Rosa*	Moshé Mizrahi
	Iphigenia	Michael Cacoyannis
	Operation Thunderbolt	Menahem Golan
	A Special Day	Ettore Scola
	That Obscure Object of Desire	Luis Buñuel
1978 (51st)	*Get Out Your Handkerchiefs*	Bertrand Blier
	The Glass Cell	Hans W. Geißendörfer
	Hungarians	Zoltán Fábri
	Viva Italia!	Mario Monicelli Dino Risi Ettore Scola
	White Bim Black Ear	Stanislav Rostotsky
1979 (52nd)	*The Tin Drum*	Volker Schlöndorff
	The Maids of Wilko	Andrzej Wajda
	Mama Turns a Hundred	Carlos Saura
	A Simple Story	Claude Sautet
	To Forget Venice	Franco Brusati
1980 (53rd)	*Moscow Does Not Believe in Tears*	Vladimir Menshov
	Confidence	István Szabó
	Kagemusha	Akira Kurosawa
	The Last Metro	François Truffaut
	The Nest	Jaime de Armiñán
1981 (54th)	*Mephisto*	István Szabó
	The Boat Is Full	Markus Imhoof
	Man of Iron	Andrzej Wajda
	Muddy River	Kôhei Oguri
	Three Brothers	Francesco Rosi
1982 (55th)	*Volver a Empezar (‘To Begin Again’)*	José Luis Garci
	Alsino and the Condor	Miguel Littín
	Coup de Torchon	Bertrand Tavernier
	The Flight of the Eagle	Jan Troell
	Private Life	Yuli Raizman
1983 (56th)	*Fanny & Alexander*	Ingmar Bergman
	Carmen	Carlos Saura
	Entre Nous	Diane Kurys
	Job’s Revolt	Imre Gyöngyössy Barna Kabay
	Le Bal	Ettore Scola
1984 (57th)	*Dangerous Moves*	Richard Dembo
	Beyond the Walls	Uri Barbash
	Camila	María Luisa Bemberg
	Double Feature	José Luis Garci
	Wartime Romance	Pyotr Todorovsky
1985 (58th)	*The Official Story*	Luis Puenzo
	Angry Harvest	Agnieszka Holland
	Colonel Redl	István Szabó
	Three Men and a Cradle	Coline Serreau
	When Father Was Away on Business	Emir Kusturica
1986 (59th)	*The Assault*	Fons Rademakers
	Betty Blue	Jean-Jacques Beineix
	The Decline of the American Empire	Denys Arcand
	My Sweet Little Village	Jiří Menzel
	‘38′	Wolfgang Glück
1987 (60th)	*Babette’s Feast*	Gabriel Axel
	Au Revoir Les Enfants	Louis Malle
	Course Completed	José Luis Garci
	The Family	Ettore Scola
	Pathfinder	Nils Gaup
1988 (61st)	*Pelle the Conqueror*	Bille August
	Hanussen	István Szabó
	The Music Teacher	Gérard Corbiau
	Salaam Bombay!	Mira Nair
	Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown	Pedro Almodóvar
1989 (62nd)	*Cinema Paradiso*	Giuseppe Tornatore
	Camille Claudel	Bruno Nuytten
	Jesus of Montreal	Denys Arcand
	Waltzing Regitze	Kaspar Rostrup
	What Happened to Santiago	Jacobo Morales
1990 (63rd)	*Journey of Hope*	Xavier Koller
	Cyrano de Bergerac	Jean-Paul Rappeneau
	Ju Dou	Zhang Yimou Yang Fengliang
	The Nasty Girl	Michael Verhoeven
	Open Doors	Gianni Amelio
1991 (64th)	*Mediterraneo*	Gabriele Salvatores
	Children of Nature	Friðrik Þór Friðriksson
	The Elementary School	Jan Svěrák
	The Ox	Sven Nykvist
	Raise the Red Lantern	Zhang Yimou
1992 (65th)	*Indochine*	Régis Wargnier
	Close to Eden	Nikita Mikhalkov
	Daens	Stijn Coninx
	A Place in the World	Adolfo Aristarain
	Schtonk!	Helmut Dietl
1993 (66th)	*Belle Époque*	Fernando Trueba
	Farewell My Concubine	Chen Kaige
	Hedd Wyn	Paul Turner
	The Scent of Green Papaya	Trần Anh Hùng
	The Wedding Banquet	Ang Lee
1994 (67th)	*Burnt by the Sun*	Nikita Mikhalkov
	Before the Rain	Milčo Mančevski
	Eat Drink Man Woman	Ang Lee
	Farinelli: Il Castrato	Gérard Corbiau
	Strawberry and Chocolate	Tomás Gutiérrez Alea Juan Carlos Tabío
1995 (68th)	*Antonia’s Line*	Marleen Gorris
	All Things Fair	Bo Widerberg
	Dust of Life	Rachid Bouchareb
	O Quatrilho	Fábio Barreto
	The Star Maker	Giuseppe Tornatore
1996 (69th)	*Kolya*	Jan Svěrák
	A Chef in Love	Nana Dzhordzhadze
	The Other Side of Sunday	Berit Nesheim
	Prisoner of the Mountains	Sergei Bodrov
	Ridicule	Patrice Leconte
1997 (70th)	*Character*	Mike van Diem
	Beyond Silence	Caroline Link
	Four Days in September	Bruno Barreto
	Secrets of the Heart	Montxo Armendáriz
	The Thief	Pavel Chukhraj
1998 (71st)	*Life Is Beautiful*	Roberto Benigni
	Central Station	Walter Salles
	Children of Heaven	Majid Majidi
	The Grandfather	José Luis Garci
	Tango	Carlos Saura
1999 (72nd)	*All About My Mother*	Pedro Almodóvar
	Caravan	Eric Valli
	East-West	Régis Wargnier
	Solomon and Gaenor	Paul Morrison
	Under the Sun	Colin Nutley
2000 (73rd)	*Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon*	Ang Lee
	Amores Perros	Alejandro González Iñárritu
	Divided We Fall	Jan Hřebejk
	Everybody Famous!	Dominique Deruddere
	The Taste of Others	Agnès Jaoui
2001 (74th)	*No Man’s Land*	Danis Tanović
	Amélie	Jean-Pierre Jeunet
	Elling	Petter Næss
	Lagaan	Ashutosh Gowariker
	Son of the Bride	Juan J. Campanella
2002 (75th)	*Nowhere in Africa*	Caroline Link
	The Crime of Father Amaro	Carlos Carrera
	Hero	Zhang Yimou
	The Man Without a Past	Aki Kaurismäki
	Zus & Zo	Paula van der Oest
2003 (76th)	*The Barbarian Invasions*	Denys Arcand
	Evil	Mikael Håfström
	The Twilight Samurai	Yoji Yamada
	Twin Sisters	Ben Sombogaart
	Želary	Ondřej Trojan
2004 (77th)	*The Sea Inside*	Alejandro Amenábar
	As It Is in Heaven	Kay Pollak
	The Chorus	Christophe Barratier
	Downfall	Oliver Hirschbiegel
	Yesterday	Darrell Roodt
2005 (78th)	*Tsotsi*	Gavin Hood
	Don’t Tell	Cristina Comencini
	Joyeux Noël	Christian Carion
	Paradise Now	Hany Abu-Assad
	Sophie Scholl – The Final Days	Marc Rothemund
2006 (79th)	*The Lives of Others*	Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck
	After the Wedding	Susanne Bier
	Days of Glory	Rachid Bouchareb
	Pan’s Labyrinth	Guillermo del Toro
	Water	Deepa Mehta
2007 (80th)	*The Counterfeiters*	Stefan Ruzowitzky
	12	Nikita Mikhalkov
	Beaufort	Joseph Cedar
	Katyń	Andrzej Wajda
	Mongol	Sergei Bodrov
2008 (81st)	*Departures*	Yojiro Takita
	The Baader Meinhof Complex	Uli Edel
	The Class	Laurent Cantet
	Revanche	Götz Spielmann
	Waltz with Bashir	Ari Folman
2009 (82nd)	Ajami	Scandar Copti Yaron Shani
	El Secreto de Sus Ojos	Juan José Campanella
	The Milk of Sorrow	Claudia Llosa
	Un Prophète	Jacques Audiard
	The White Ribbon	Michael Haneke

magasa's weblog

Old is New

是枝裕和

The Spam Locker

继续重选50多年来的奥斯卡最佳外语片